Taliaferro “Toliver” Langford Scott was born in 1819 in South Carolina; his parents remain unidentified. At first, I believed he was the son of Taliaferro “Toliver” L. Scott and Nancy Wright of Spartanburg District, which seemed reasonable until new evidence surfaced. In March, another researcher contacted me after reading my sketch on Anthony Scott of Culpeper County, Virginia. She had traced the same Culpeper “love and affection” deed I had followed, but her line ran through Elizabeth (Scott) Stone—sister of the Culpeper‑born Toliver (1784). When she shared a Spartanburg Petition for Partition filed by W. B. Scott, it listed all heirs of Toliver (1784), and my Toliver was not among them. That document proved that the Culpeper‑born Toliver did not have a son named Toliver, so the Anderson County man must belong to a different branch of the family.
![]() |
Petition for Partition filed in the Spartanburg District Court of Ordinary by W. B. Scott |
As I continued researching, a completely different sibling group emerged for the Anderson County Toliver—Carter C., Mitchell B., Jefferson A., William H., Joseph, and Mary Scott. DNA evidence supports a connection to Anthony’s grandson, Cornelius Scott, but without a document naming his parents, Anderson County Toliver’s position in the Scott line that traces back to Anthony Scott is unsettled for me.
While this was disappointing, I made a major discovery while reviewing Scott records on FamilySearch: Toliver (of Anderson) had been married twice, not once as I had believed. His first marriage occurred before March 1836, when he and Eliza E. Strickland, daughter of Burrell and Emilla “Emily” Strickland, appeared together in an Equity Court notice in the Pendleton Messenger. They continued the Strickland suit through 1837 and 1838, filing their receipt in full on November 24, 1838, confirming they had received Eliza’s inheritance. Later filings show that Toliver had died by the early 1850s and identify their three children as Newton, Amanda Elizabeth, and Eliza Scott. I descend from their daughter Amanda.
By August 1839, Toliver had moved into Anderson Village and purchased six town lots from Richard Prince. Prince held only a bond for title, meaning he did not yet have the deed, but Toliver paid the full price and took possession anyway. He lived on and improved the property for more than a decade, though the incomplete title later caused legal complications.
Eliza died shortly after Amanda’s birth in September 1839. On January 6, 1840, Toliver married Melvina “Lavina or Vina” Parker, forming a blended household that included Newton, Eliza, and Amanda, as well as Toliver and Lavina’s children—Martha Ellen, Langford J., Mary F., and Rosanna T. Scott. The 1840 census shows the family in Anderson District. By the late 1840s, Toliver had established himself as a wagon maker and blacksmith.
Court records show that Toliver had been sued for unpaid notes as early as 1841, a pattern of financial strain that continued throughout the decade. Court records also show Toliver appearing as a witness in local civil cases, such as a subpoena issued in 1846 in a suit between James Ingram and John Dickinson.
In a January 1849 advertisement, Toliver offered one‑ to four‑horse wagons “of his own make,” guaranteed his workmanship, and invited custom orders. He also sold wagons on Sale Day, demonstrating both skill and business sense.
![]() |
The Abbeville Banner, Abbeville, South Carolina, January 13, 1849 |
In 1850, the Scott family lived in the Western Division of Anderson District. Toliver, age 31, worked as a blacksmith with real estate valued at $2,000. Most of the children attended school, and Newton was listed as an apprentice—likely learning his father’s trade. A young man named Jeptha Scott lived with them, though his relationship is unknown. The agricultural schedule shows only a small farm—no horses or cattle, just a few sheep and pigs, and modest grain production—confirming that blacksmithing was Toliver’s primary livelihood.
Toliver’s financial troubles came to a head in October 1850, when the Court of Common Pleas issued a writ ordering sheriffs across South Carolina to seize him and bring him to court to answer a debt claim filed by Warren R. Webb. Before the case could be resolved, Toliver died without a will on January 12, 1851. His widow petitioned for administration, but the Ordinary appointed Andrew O. Norris on January 30. The estate inventory listed household goods, blacksmith tools, livestock, two enslaved adults, and numerous unpaid accounts owed to Toliver, yet the estate ultimately lacked the assets needed to cover his debts.
Toliver also owned two Anderson town lots—Nos. 41 and 43 in Square 14—one containing his blacksmith shop and the other a house. Because the estate lacked clear title to all six lots, Norris went to the Court of Equity in 1852 to clear the title and authorize their sale. Surveyor James Gilmer resurveyed the property, and the court ordered the lots sold in September 1853 to satisfy debts.
![]() |
Survey of Toliver’s six Anderson Village lots |
In June 1852, the court appointed a guardian ad litem for Toliver’s three minor Strickland‑line children (with his first wife Eliza)—Newton, Amanda, and Eliza—during the ongoing Strickland estate proceedings, ensuring their inheritance rights were protected.
By 1863, Toliver’s former Anderson Lots 41 and 43 had passed into the hands of Charleston financier George A. Trenholm, noting the building long known as ‘Scott’s shop’ and tracing their ownership through Elias Earle to Trenholm.
Mitchell B. Scott’s probate records from 1874–1876 helped document Toliver’s family. When Mitchell’s widow petitioned the court to sell land to pay his debts, the court listed Mitchell’s living siblings and the heirs of those who had already died. Toliver was included among the deceased siblings, and his place was represented by his daughters—Amanda Holland, Eliza Bolt, Ellen Simmons, Mary F. Turner, and Rosannah Mahaffey—showing that these were his surviving children and that he had died well before 1874.
Toliver’s presence in Anderson County records continued into the 1870s, when deeds tracing the chain of title for his Anderson town lots—Nos. 41 and 43 in Square 14—described them as “formerly owned by Toliver Scott.” A federal court deed from 1873, issued during the Fraser & Trenholm bankruptcy, again identified these lots as part of Toliver’s 1842 estate sale, preserving both their boundaries and his place in the early development of Anderson’s town center.
Toliver’s life in Anderson County is now far clearer than when I began this research, yet one question remains unresolved: who were his parents? The evidence firmly rules out the Spartanburg line descending from Toliver Scott (1784), and DNA connections instead point toward an unplaced branch of the wider Scott family descending from Anthony Scott of Culpeper County. Matches to the line of Cornelius Scott strengthen that possibility, but no surviving record has yet named Toliver’s parents outright. His parentage remains just beyond the surviving evidence, likely preserved somewhere in the early Anderson, Pendleton, or upstate Scott records that have yet to come to light.
References
- Anderson County, South Carolina, Conveyance Records 1873–1875, images 87 and 141, FamilySearch.
- Anderson County, South Carolina, Court Records 1840, image 688, FamilySearch.
- Anderson County, South Carolina, Court Records 1846–1847, images 313–314, FamilySearch.
- Anderson County, South Carolina, Court Records 1852, images 7–57, FamilySearch.
- Anderson County, South Carolina, Court Records 1852–1853, images 8–90, FamilySearch.
- Anderson County, South Carolina, Judicial Estate Records 1849–1851, image 691, FamilySearch.
- Anderson County, South Carolina, Land Records 1852–1855, 1849–1852, images 406–407 and 532, FamilySearch.
- Anderson County, South Carolina, Land Records 1872–1873, image 489, FamilySearch.
- Anderson County, South Carolina, Probate Records 1828–1878, images 406–411 and 619–647, FamilySearch.
- Anderson County, South Carolina, Probate Records 1853–1863, 1840–1853, 1863–1868, image 250, FamilySearch.
- Anderson, South Carolina, Judicial Estate Records 1849–1851, images 688–693, FamilySearch.
- Anderson, South Carolina, Judicial Estate Records 1853–1854, images 260–261, FamilySearch.
- Charleston, South Carolina, Conveyance Records 1857–1867, image 872, FamilySearch.
- Deed Book A, 1749–1753, Culpeper County, Virginia: Culpeper, Deed Books 1749–1753, image 138, FamilySearch.
- History of Aaron Hall and Clementina Ann (Norris) Hall, letter written by Aaron Hall Holland to Samuel Jackson Holland, May 15, 1964.
- Lavina Scott, South Carolina, U.S., Wills and Probate Records, 1670–1980.
- Parker, Vina, South Carolina, U.S., Compiled Marriage Index, 1641–1965.
- Pendleton, South Carolina, Newspapers 1839, 1837, image 19 (Pendleton Messenger, March 22, 1837), FamilySearch.
- Spartanburg, South Carolina, Real Estate Records 1853–1881, images 177–178, FamilySearch.
- Tolaver Scott, plat for 212.5 acres on fork of North and South Tiger Rivers, Spartanburgh District, surveyed by George Nicholls, October 27, 1830.
- U.S. Federal Census, Anderson, South Carolina, 1840.
- U.S. Federal Census, Spartanburg, South Carolina, 1830.
- U.S. Federal Census, Western Division, District of Anderson, South Carolina, 1850.
- U.S., Selected Federal Census Non-Population Schedules (Agriculture), Anderson, South Carolina, 1850.
- Wagons for Sale, The Abbeville Banner, Abbeville, South Carolina, January 13, 1849.

































