Looking for a Patriot, Found Anthony Scott Instead

As I continued my 250th‑anniversary project on Revolutionary War–era ancestors, I expected my next subject to be another patriot. Instead, a chance search led me to Anthony Scott—a man I hadn’t even known existed two days earlier. He wasn’t a soldier but discovering him turned out to be far more meaningful to me than finding another veteran.

My plan had been to look for records related to Moses Holland, my 5th great‑grandfather, who is said to have served as a drummer during the war. When that search turned up nothing, I shifted to Leroy Thomas Holland, Moses’ great‑grandson and my 2nd great‑grandfather. Leroy served during the Civil War, not the Revolution, so I didn’t expect to find anything relevant—but you never know. And that small detour is what sent me down the rabbit hole.

I was already searching Anderson County, South Carolina records, so entered Leroy’s name. A document listing Leroy, his wife Amanda, and a “Lankford Scott” immediately caught my attention. Amanda’s maiden name was Scott, and I remembered finding men with the middle name “Langford” when trying to identify her parents. Given that my own maiden name is Lankford, that detail had stuck with me.

Results from FamilySearch full text search

The link led to an 1852 estate proceeding for Mitchell B. Scott, which confirmed the family connection. In settling Mitchell’s estate, the court listed his heirs‑at‑law: his surviving brothers—Joseph, William H., Carter, and Jefferson A. Scott—and the children of siblings who had died before him. Among these was “Amanda Holland, wife of Leroy Holland, Anderson District,” named in place of her father, Toliver L. Scott. Her siblings—Eliza Bolt, A. Ellen Holland, Lankford Scott, Mary F. Turner, and Rosannah Mahaffy—appear with her as Toliver’s surviving children, each inheriting his share. The record also includes the children of Mitchell’s sister Mary Scott Hamby. For Amanda, this document provides formal legal proof of her lineage and firmly places her within the Scott family of Anderson and Spartanburg.

South Carolina estate-distribution record for Mitchell B. Scott
(Amanda’s uncle)

Back in 2021, I had tentatively identified Amanda’s parents as Taliaferro Langford Scott and Melvina E. Parker, but I had never been able to confirm it. Four and a half years later, as I followed one clue after another—estate files, guardianship records, land descriptions—the name Cornelius A. Scott surfaced. Then another name. And another. Suddenly, I wasn’t looking for a Revolutionary War soldier anymore. I was staring at the outline of an entire Scott lineage stretching back through two men named Taliaferro “Toliver” Langford Scott (father and son), through Cornelius A. Scott, through Samuel Scott, and finally to a man I had never expected to find: Anthony Scott of Culpeper County, Virginia, born around 1690.

The image below is the Scott line reconstructed from the records, showing the path from Anthony Scott in early‑1700s Virginia down to Amanda Scott Holland.

What began as a routine record check became a multi‑generational reconstruction—a chain of fathers, sons, land deeds, and migrations that connected my Amanda Scott of Anderson County, South Carolina (and later Whitfield County, Georgia) to a man living on the Virginia frontier in the early 1700s. I didn’t just confirm Amanda’s parents. I uncovered the identity of my 7th great‑grandfather, a man whose existence I hadn’t even suspected when I sat down to research that day.

It all started with a simple question: Did Revolutionary War service records exist in the FamilySearch archive for Moses Holland? Once I pivoted to searching for Scotts, the records led me through Anderson and Spartanburg in South Carolina and eventually to Culpeper County, Virginia. A series of estate documents from Anderson District kept pointing to Cornelius A. Scott. At first, he was just a name—someone involved in land transactions, someone whose children appeared alongside Toliver’s in legal filings. But the more I read, the clearer it became: Cornelius wasn’t a neighbor or a witness. He was family.

And then came the breakthrough. Buried in a chain of deeds and probate references was the unmistakable clue: Cornelius A. Scott wasn’t just connected to Toliver Sr.—he was Toliver’s father. That one realization opened the door to an entirely new generation. And once Cornelius appeared, the records began to unfold—land transfers in Culpeper County, boundary descriptions that matched across decades, and a pattern of inheritance that pointed unmistakably to Anthony Scott.

This little detour reminded me how unpredictable genealogy can be. A simple search for a drummer boy led me through estate files, land records, and finally to an ancestor I hadn’t even known to look for. Anthony Scott wasn’t the patriot I set out to find but discovering him added a whole new chapter to my family’s story.

I'll share more on Anthony Scott in April, but meanwhile, if you haven’t explored the Full Text-Search feature on FamilySearch, I highly recommend it. It’s very powerful. 

References

• Anderson County, South Carolina, Court Records 1800–1869, image 84, FamilySearch.
• Anderson County, South Carolina, Probate Records 1828–1878, image 477, FamilySearch.
• Deed Book D, 1762-1765, Culpeper County, Virginia: Culpeper. Deed Books 1762–1765, image 350, FamilySearch.
• Deed Book GG, 1813-1817, Culpeper County, Virginia: Culpeper. Deed Books 1813–1817, images 303–304, FamilySearch.
• Deed Book K, 1779-1781, Culpeper County, Virginia: Culpeper. Deed Books 1779–1781, image 68, FamilySearch.
• Deed Book L, 1781-1783, Culpeper County, Virginia: Culpeper. Deed Books 1781–1783, image 144, FamilySearch.
• Personal Property Tax Book, 1782-1789, Culpeper County, Virginia: Culpeper. Personal Property Tax Records 1782–1789, image 60, FamilySearch.